Parliament Sitting on 12 January 2022

QUESTION FOR ORAL ANSWER


3. Ms Tin Pei Ling: To ask the Minister for Communications and Information in view of IMDA’s assessment of the book “Red Lines: Political Cartoons and the Struggle Against Censorship” to be objectionable under the Undesirable Publications Act (UPA) (a) whether a redacted version of the book with the objectionable offensive images removed, will be considered by IMDA for the publication of the book in Singapore; and (b) how does the classification of the book compare with other publications previously deemed objectionable under the UPA.

4. Mr Sitoh Yih Pin: To ask the Minister for Communications and Information arising from IMDA’s assessment of the book “Red Lines: Political Cartoons and the Struggle Against Censorship” to be objectionable under the Undesirable Publications Act (UPA), whether a redacted version of the book can be considered for publication.

Answer:

1. The Infocomm Media Development Authority (IMDA) has assessed the publication “Red Lines: Political Cartoons and the Struggle Against Censorship” to be objectionable under the Undesirable Publications Act (UPA) as the book contains images that denigrate religions, including the reproduction of Charlie Hebdo’s cartoons of Prophet Muhammad.

2. The Government has made very clear its views on the Charlie Hebdo cartoons, and on offensive images which denigrate religions and religious figures. We do not allow any religious group to be insulted or attacked, because hate speech and offensive content can easily be normalised and lead to deep social divides if left unchecked. To preserve racial and religious harmony in Singapore, we take a firm stance on such content regardless of their purpose of publication.

3. In the last five years, IMDA has assessed six other publications besides “Red Lines” to be objectionable for denigrating various religious communities. These publications were assessed to be likely to cause feelings of enmity, hatred, ill-will or hostility between different racial or religious groups and are thus not allowed for distribution in Singapore. For example, in 2020, IMDA deemed the book “Understanding the Evil of Innovation” objectionable as the book contained strong denigratory references towards Judaism and Christianity. Removal of the offensive content will not automatically lead to these publications being allowed for distribution. Revised versions would have to be re-assessed holistically; none of the publishers have sought to do so.

4. “Red Lines” was launched in the United States of America on 31 August 2021, before IMDA took a decision on its suitability for distribution in Singapore. There are multiple objectionable images throughout the book which are racially and religiously offensive. Singapore’s position on such content is well-known. The Singapore distributor of “Red Lines” itself, Alkem Company, had concerns about some of the book’s images being objectionable when they first approached IMDA. In response to IMDA’s public explanation of its reasons for assessing “Red Lines” to be objectionable and unsuitable for distribution in Singapore, the authors Dr Cherian George and Mr Sonny Liew issued a public statement in which they expressed the view that the “regulator has opted for additional caution”. It should be noted however, that even with such caution, our society is not free from frictions that strain racial and religious harmony. 

5. At this point, Alkem and the authors have not confirmed their specific plans on the treatment of the offensive content. If and when they do so, they can approach IMDA to assess the suitability of a revised version of “Red Lines” for distribution in Singapore.

6. To ensure that publications that have been deemed objectionable are not distributed in Singapore, IMDA maintains a database of these publications which importers and book distributors can refer to. It is an offence for any person to import, sell, distribute, make or reproduce an objectionable publication. The penalty is a fine not exceeding $5,000 or jail not exceeding 12 months or both.
 
Opening Speech by Mrs Josephine Teo, Minister for Communications and Information, at the Official Opening of the National Integrated Centre for Evaluation, on 18 May 2022 Speeches Cyber Security 18 May 22
Speech by Dr Janil Puthucheary, Senior Minister of State for Communications and Information, at the MOU Signing between Singapore Women in Tech and Polytechnics and launch of Cross-Polytechnic Girls in Tech Committee, on 13 May 2022 Speeches Infocomm Media 13 May 22
Opening Address by Dr Janil Puthucheary, Senior Minister of State for Communications and Information, at Inaugural Association of Information Security Professionals (AISP) Internet-of-Things (IOT) Innovation Day 2022 Speeches Infocomm Media 11 May 22
MCI response to PQ on Tracking of Local Companies which Experienced Cyber Attacks over Past Two Years and Measure to Equip Companies with Capabilities to Enhance Cyber Resilience Parliament QAs Cyber Security 09 May 22
MCI response to PQ on Annual Projected Growth of Freelancers in Infocomms Technology and Media Industries from 2022 to 2025 Parliament QAs Infocomm Media 09 May 22
MCI response to PQ on Number of Overseas Scam Calls Reported in 2021 and 2022 and Viability of Call Blocking Option for Users Parliament QAs Cyber Security 09 May 22
MCI response to PQ on Response to Recent REACH Survey on Attitudes Towards LGBTQ and Considerations Behind Survey Questions Parliament QAs Others 09 May 22
Speech by Mrs Josephine Teo, Minister for Communications and Information, at SCS Tech Leader Awards on 6 May 2022 Speeches Infocomm Media 06 May 22
Speech by Dr Janil Puthucheary, Senior Minister of State, Ministry of Communications and Information at the launch of Oneberry Technologies’ Regional HQ on 6 May 2022 Speeches Others 06 May 22
Opening Remarks by Dr Janil Puthucheary, Senior Minister of State, Ministry of Communications and Information at the Launch of the “3M Girls Can Tinker” Initiative on 28 April 2022 Speeches Infocomm Media, Government Technology 29 Apr 22
Remarks by Mrs Josephine Teo, Minister of Communications and Information, at SingPost Buka Puasa Event on 20 April 2022 Speeches Infocomm Media 21 Apr 22
Opening Remarks by Mrs Josephine Teo, Minister of Communications and Information, at the launch of Tamil Cholai on 16 April 2022 Speeches Libraries 16 Apr 22
Keynote Speech by Mrs Josephine Teo, Minister of Communications and Information, at the World AI Cannes Festival on 14 April 2022 Speeches Others 14 Apr 22
Singapore and Indonesia Reaffirm Commitment to Stronger Digital Cooperation to Leverage Opportunities in the Digital Economy Press Releases Infocomm Media 12 Apr 22
Remarks by Mrs Josephine Teo, Minister of Communications and Information, at the Opening of Lazada One on 11 Apr 2022 Speeches Infocomm Media 11 Apr 22
Closing Speech by Mrs Josephine Teo, Minister of Communications and Information, at the Motion on Singapore Women's Development on 5 April 2022 Speeches, Parliament QAs Others 05 Apr 22
Speech by Ms Sim Ann, Senior Minister of State for Foreign Affairs and National Development, and Co-Chair of Sunlight AfA, at the Motion of Singapore Women's Development, on 5 April 2022 Speeches, Parliament QAs Others 05 Apr 22
Speech by Parliamentary Secretary Rahayu Mahzam at the Motion on Singapore Women's Development on 5 April 2022 Speeches, Parliament QAs Others 05 Apr 22
Opening Speech by Mrs Josephine Teo, Minister of Communications and Information, at the Motion on Singapore Women’s Development on 5 April 2022 Speeches, Parliament QAs Others 05 Apr 22
MCI response to PQ on Negotiations Between Government and Singapore Press Holdings Ltd Before Establishment of SPH Media Trust Parliament QAs Public Comms, Infocomm Media 04 Apr 22
MCI response to PQ on Breakdown of Households with Landline Telephone Connection by Housing and Line Type Parliament QAs Infocomm Media 04 Apr 22
MCI response to PQ on Reasons for Recent Data Breach of Local Retail Website and Measures to Ensure Security and Protection of Customer Data Parliament QAs Personal Data, Cyber Security 04 Apr 22
MCI response to PQ on Efforts at Raising Public Awareness of Singapore's National Interests with regard to Russia-Ukraine Conflict and Countering Misinformation Parliament QAs Public Comms 04 Apr 22
MCI response to PQ on Shutdown of Anti-SMS Spoofing Registry Parliament QAs Infocomm Media 04 Apr 22